Architects need a fair selection process
Real Estate

Architects need a fair selection process

In India, speaking of architecture, more value is attached to the quantity of experience than quality of work. 

It is typical of architectural firms to get debarred and come back. “One does not get debarred owing to failure of quality of deliverables in a particular project,” says Kalhan Mattoo, Principal & Co- founder, Office of Kalhan. “It is usually about relationship management and not being able to fulfill some professional, and more importantly, personal commitments.”

 “As the system of allotting projects is not design-based, I doubt the quality, efficiency and aesthetics in overall design,” Architect Gurunath Dalvi adds.
Indrajit S Kembhavi, Partner, Kembhavi Architecture Foundation (KAF), also suggests that excellence and quality should be the criteria, and the scale of fees should be standard. “An architect has to be selected on merit rather than lower fees.” Calling most competitions and tenders unfair with a bias towards a few firms, he says the very concept of tendering is wrong and leads to substandard work as some architects quote low fees just to pick up projects and are eventually unable to deliver. It is impossible for quality firms to render services at such low prices. 

Selection by competition
 “If we want international standards of projects,” says Kembhavi, “it is mandatory to evaluate architects on benchmarks of design delivery capacities rather than the tendering process, which is often awarded to bad designs owing to a lower bid.” Dalvi suggest that the selection of architects for large-scale projects should be on the basis of an open design competition on the fee scale recommended by Council of Architecture (CoA), New Delhi.

Debmalya Guha, Principal Architect and Planner, Pace Consultants, considers himself fortunate to have experienced the benefit of a design competition. “In 2001, when I had just graduated, Kolkata Municipal Corporation (KMC) decided to rebuild a century-old theatre hall, the Star Theatre, which was gutted in a fire in 1990,” he recalls. Possibly for the first time in the history of KMC, a design competition was held with the only eligibility criterion being the architectural licence of CoA, in which almost all the senior architects and quite a few junior ones in the city participated—Guha, along with a couple of friends, was among them. With a jury comprising the two senior-most architects in Kolkata, the entire process was coordinated by then chief architect of KMC, Debasish Kar. “The judgement took place without disclosing the names of the participants to the jurors,” Guha shares. “They shortlisted four design schemes without any idea who the architects were. And we were among the four, the youngest team.” The jury then called in the four teams. “We were asked to clarify some structural aspects of our design and give a more detailed elevation in the second round of the competition. And, then, we were unanimously selected as winners! We received support from KMC and guidance from senior architects, and successfully completed the project within the stipulated time in 2004.”

It has been 15 years since the inauguration of Star Theatre—and we can only wait for more such success stories!

SHRIYAL SETHUMADHAVAN

In India, speaking of architecture, more value is attached to the quantity of experience than quality of work. It is typical of architectural firms to get debarred and come back. “One does not get debarred owing to failure of quality of deliverables in a particular project,” says Kalhan Mattoo, Principal & Co- founder, Office of Kalhan. “It is usually about relationship management and not being able to fulfill some professional, and more importantly, personal commitments.” “As the system of allotting projects is not design-based, I doubt the quality, efficiency and aesthetics in overall design,” Architect Gurunath Dalvi adds.Indrajit S Kembhavi, Partner, Kembhavi Architecture Foundation (KAF), also suggests that excellence and quality should be the criteria, and the scale of fees should be standard. “An architect has to be selected on merit rather than lower fees.” Calling most competitions and tenders unfair with a bias towards a few firms, he says the very concept of tendering is wrong and leads to substandard work as some architects quote low fees just to pick up projects and are eventually unable to deliver. It is impossible for quality firms to render services at such low prices. Selection by competition “If we want international standards of projects,” says Kembhavi, “it is mandatory to evaluate architects on benchmarks of design delivery capacities rather than the tendering process, which is often awarded to bad designs owing to a lower bid.” Dalvi suggest that the selection of architects for large-scale projects should be on the basis of an open design competition on the fee scale recommended by Council of Architecture (CoA), New Delhi.Debmalya Guha, Principal Architect and Planner, Pace Consultants, considers himself fortunate to have experienced the benefit of a design competition. “In 2001, when I had just graduated, Kolkata Municipal Corporation (KMC) decided to rebuild a century-old theatre hall, the Star Theatre, which was gutted in a fire in 1990,” he recalls. Possibly for the first time in the history of KMC, a design competition was held with the only eligibility criterion being the architectural licence of CoA, in which almost all the senior architects and quite a few junior ones in the city participated—Guha, along with a couple of friends, was among them. With a jury comprising the two senior-most architects in Kolkata, the entire process was coordinated by then chief architect of KMC, Debasish Kar. “The judgement took place without disclosing the names of the participants to the jurors,” Guha shares. “They shortlisted four design schemes without any idea who the architects were. And we were among the four, the youngest team.” The jury then called in the four teams. “We were asked to clarify some structural aspects of our design and give a more detailed elevation in the second round of the competition. And, then, we were unanimously selected as winners! We received support from KMC and guidance from senior architects, and successfully completed the project within the stipulated time in 2004.”It has been 15 years since the inauguration of Star Theatre—and we can only wait for more such success stories!SHRIYAL SETHUMADHAVAN

Next Story
Infrastructure Transport

PM to Inaugurate Indore Metro Phase 1 and Datia Satna Airports on May 31

Prime Minister Narendra Modi is scheduled to inaugurate the first phase of the Indore Metro Rail project, along with the Datia and Satna airports, via video conferencing during his visit to Bhopal on May 31, according to a senior Madhya Pradesh cabinet official.During his day-long visit to Bhopal, the Prime Minister will also participate in a conference organized to commemorate the 300th birth anniversary of Devi Ahilyabai Holkar, the historic queen of the Malwa kingdom, now part of Madhya Pradesh, as stated by the Parliamentary Affairs Minister and Cabinet spokesperson Kailash Vijayvargiya.It..

Next Story
Infrastructure Transport

Kochi Metro Holds Talks with BPCL to Restore Greenery on Medians

Kochi Metro Rail (KMRL), facing increasing criticism for not maintaining the green spaces along the medians in the metro corridor, has initiated discussions with Bharat Petroleum Corporation (BPCL) and the Ernakulam District Horticulture Society to revive the project.Sources reveal that KMRL is also making fresh efforts to find sponsors to care for and maintain the gardens located between the metro pillars. Previously, several sponsors had withdrawn, which led to the neglect of these green areas.There are 989 medians along the 28-km Kochi Metro stretch. Of these, 465 are under the National Hig..

Next Story
Infrastructure Transport

Rajasthan CM Approves DPR for Jaipur Metro Phase-2 Expansion

Rajasthan Chief Minister Bhajanlal Sharma approved the detailed project report (DPR) of Jaipur Metro Phase-2 and forwarded it to the Central Government.The construction work for the project is set to begin once the Union Ministry of Housing and Urban Affairs grants approval to the DPR.Phase 2 of Jaipur Metro had been announced in the state budget for 2025-26.The project, covering a 42.80-km stretch from Todi Mode to Prahladpura, will be implemented by the Rajasthan Metro Rail Corporation—a newly formed 50:50 joint venture between the state and Central governments. The corporation will be res..

Advertisement

Advertisement

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

Get daily newsletters around different themes from Construction world.

STAY CONNECTED

Advertisement

Advertisement

Advertisement

Advertisement

Talk to us?