Gujarat HC Rules 18% GST on Leasehold Land Transfer Inapplicable
ECONOMY & POLICY

Gujarat HC Rules 18% GST on Leasehold Land Transfer Inapplicable

The Gujarat High Court has ruled that Goods and Services Tax (GST) does not apply to the transfer of leasehold rights on industrial land allocated by the Gujarat Industrial Development Corporation (GIDC). This decision provides significant relief to industries involved in such transactions, removing a contentious tax burden. The judgment addresses whether GST is applicable to leasehold land transfers, offering clarity on a long-debated issue. It is expected to influence similar disputes across courts, including cases in the Bombay High Court regarding industrial land transactions by the Maharashtra Industrial Development Corporation (MIDC). Petitioners argued that leasehold land transfers should be treated as sales of land, which are exempt from GST under the law. They highlighted that the 18% GST imposed on these transactions, in addition to state-imposed stamp duties, results in cascading taxes and makes deals economically unfeasible. The ruling, issued by Justices Bhargava D Karia and D N Ray on January 3, has been welcomed by legal and tax experts. Abhishek A. Rastogi, founder of Rastogi Chambers, noted that the issue of double taxation needed scrutiny, as GST demands and show cause notices often result in additional burdens for businesses. Saurabh Agarwal, Tax Partner at EY, called the decision a landmark ruling, bringing relief and clarity to businesses. He added that GIDC's retrospective demand for 18% GST had created liabilities amounting to approximately ?8,000 crore, severely impacting MSMEs. Agarwal emphasised the broader debate over whether long-term leases equate to land sales, which predates the GST regime. The ruling is expected to act as a strong precedent, but experts believe a final resolution will require intervention from the Supreme Court or clarification by the GST Council to ensure legal certainty and a more favourable investment environment. (CNBCTV18)

The Gujarat High Court has ruled that Goods and Services Tax (GST) does not apply to the transfer of leasehold rights on industrial land allocated by the Gujarat Industrial Development Corporation (GIDC). This decision provides significant relief to industries involved in such transactions, removing a contentious tax burden. The judgment addresses whether GST is applicable to leasehold land transfers, offering clarity on a long-debated issue. It is expected to influence similar disputes across courts, including cases in the Bombay High Court regarding industrial land transactions by the Maharashtra Industrial Development Corporation (MIDC). Petitioners argued that leasehold land transfers should be treated as sales of land, which are exempt from GST under the law. They highlighted that the 18% GST imposed on these transactions, in addition to state-imposed stamp duties, results in cascading taxes and makes deals economically unfeasible. The ruling, issued by Justices Bhargava D Karia and D N Ray on January 3, has been welcomed by legal and tax experts. Abhishek A. Rastogi, founder of Rastogi Chambers, noted that the issue of double taxation needed scrutiny, as GST demands and show cause notices often result in additional burdens for businesses. Saurabh Agarwal, Tax Partner at EY, called the decision a landmark ruling, bringing relief and clarity to businesses. He added that GIDC's retrospective demand for 18% GST had created liabilities amounting to approximately ?8,000 crore, severely impacting MSMEs. Agarwal emphasised the broader debate over whether long-term leases equate to land sales, which predates the GST regime. The ruling is expected to act as a strong precedent, but experts believe a final resolution will require intervention from the Supreme Court or clarification by the GST Council to ensure legal certainty and a more favourable investment environment. (CNBCTV18)

Next Story
Infrastructure Energy

Mizoram To Build Rs 139 Billion Pumped Storage Power Plant

Mizoram Chief Minister Lalduhoma on Friday announced plans to construct a 2,400 MW pumped storage hydroelectric power plant in Hnahthial district, marking a major step towards achieving energy self-sufficiency in the state. Addressing the Mizo Students’ Union general conference in Hnahthial town, the Chief Minister said the plant would be developed across the Darzo Nallah, a tributary of the Tuipui river. Once operational, the project is expected to play a pivotal role in meeting Mizoram’s rising electricity demand and reducing dependence on imported power. Officials from the State Power..

Next Story
Infrastructure Energy

Centre Plans Nationwide Opening Of Power Retail Market

India is preparing to open up its retail electricity market to private companies nationwide, effectively ending the long-standing monopoly of state-run power distributors in most regions, according to a draft bill released by the Union Power Ministry on Friday. The move will enable major private sector players — including Adani Enterprises, Tata Power, Torrent Power, and CESC — to expand their presence across the country’s electricity distribution landscape. A similar reform attempt in 2022 had faced strong opposition from state-run distribution companies (discoms), which currently dom..

Next Story
Infrastructure Energy

CEA Sets 100 GW Nuclear Target For India By 2047

In a landmark step marking its 52nd Foundation Day, the Central Electricity Authority (CEA) unveiled an ambitious roadmap to develop 100 gigawatts (GW) of nuclear power capacity by 2047, aligning with India’s long-term Net-Zero commitment and energy security objectives. The event, held at the Central Water Commission auditorium in New Delhi’s R.K. Puram, was attended by Pankaj Agarwal, Secretary, Ministry of Power, who served as the Chief Guest. The roadmap sets out a detailed plan to expand India’s nuclear capacity from its current level of approximately 8,180 MW as of early 2025, outl..

Advertisement

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

Get daily newsletters around different themes from Construction world.

STAY CONNECTED

Advertisement

Advertisement

Advertisement

Talk to us?