+
Gujarat HC Rules 18% GST on Leasehold Land Transfer Inapplicable
ECONOMY & POLICY

Gujarat HC Rules 18% GST on Leasehold Land Transfer Inapplicable

The Gujarat High Court has ruled that Goods and Services Tax (GST) does not apply to the transfer of leasehold rights on industrial land allocated by the Gujarat Industrial Development Corporation (GIDC). This decision provides significant relief to industries involved in such transactions, removing a contentious tax burden. The judgment addresses whether GST is applicable to leasehold land transfers, offering clarity on a long-debated issue. It is expected to influence similar disputes across courts, including cases in the Bombay High Court regarding industrial land transactions by the Maharashtra Industrial Development Corporation (MIDC). Petitioners argued that leasehold land transfers should be treated as sales of land, which are exempt from GST under the law. They highlighted that the 18% GST imposed on these transactions, in addition to state-imposed stamp duties, results in cascading taxes and makes deals economically unfeasible. The ruling, issued by Justices Bhargava D Karia and D N Ray on January 3, has been welcomed by legal and tax experts. Abhishek A. Rastogi, founder of Rastogi Chambers, noted that the issue of double taxation needed scrutiny, as GST demands and show cause notices often result in additional burdens for businesses. Saurabh Agarwal, Tax Partner at EY, called the decision a landmark ruling, bringing relief and clarity to businesses. He added that GIDC's retrospective demand for 18% GST had created liabilities amounting to approximately ?8,000 crore, severely impacting MSMEs. Agarwal emphasised the broader debate over whether long-term leases equate to land sales, which predates the GST regime. The ruling is expected to act as a strong precedent, but experts believe a final resolution will require intervention from the Supreme Court or clarification by the GST Council to ensure legal certainty and a more favourable investment environment. (CNBCTV18)

The Gujarat High Court has ruled that Goods and Services Tax (GST) does not apply to the transfer of leasehold rights on industrial land allocated by the Gujarat Industrial Development Corporation (GIDC). This decision provides significant relief to industries involved in such transactions, removing a contentious tax burden. The judgment addresses whether GST is applicable to leasehold land transfers, offering clarity on a long-debated issue. It is expected to influence similar disputes across courts, including cases in the Bombay High Court regarding industrial land transactions by the Maharashtra Industrial Development Corporation (MIDC). Petitioners argued that leasehold land transfers should be treated as sales of land, which are exempt from GST under the law. They highlighted that the 18% GST imposed on these transactions, in addition to state-imposed stamp duties, results in cascading taxes and makes deals economically unfeasible. The ruling, issued by Justices Bhargava D Karia and D N Ray on January 3, has been welcomed by legal and tax experts. Abhishek A. Rastogi, founder of Rastogi Chambers, noted that the issue of double taxation needed scrutiny, as GST demands and show cause notices often result in additional burdens for businesses. Saurabh Agarwal, Tax Partner at EY, called the decision a landmark ruling, bringing relief and clarity to businesses. He added that GIDC's retrospective demand for 18% GST had created liabilities amounting to approximately ?8,000 crore, severely impacting MSMEs. Agarwal emphasised the broader debate over whether long-term leases equate to land sales, which predates the GST regime. The ruling is expected to act as a strong precedent, but experts believe a final resolution will require intervention from the Supreme Court or clarification by the GST Council to ensure legal certainty and a more favourable investment environment. (CNBCTV18)

Related Stories

Gold Stories

Next Story
Infrastructure Urban

NABARD Holds Seminar on Vigilance, Integrity and Good Governance

National Bank for Agriculture and Rural Development (NABARD) organised a seminar on “Vigilance: Strengthening Integrity and Good Governance” on 25 August 2026 at its Head Office in Mumbai as part of the ongoing Vigilance Awareness Campaign 2026 being observed from 17 August to 16 November 2026, with the theme “Probity for Prosperity."" The seminar was graced by Suresh N Patel, Former Central Vigilance Commissioner, Government of India, as the chief guest and keynote speaker.  The programme was attended by G S Rawat, Deputy Managing Director, Dr Ajay K Sood, Deputy Managing Dire..

Next Story
Equipment

XCMG Unveils World's First 14,000-Ton Ring Crane for Heavy Lifting

XCMG has announced that the first main unit of the world's first 14,000-ton ring crane has rolled off the production line, marking a historic breakthrough in ultra-heavy lifting technology. Jointly developed by XCMG and Sinopec Heavy Lifting & Transportation Co., Ltd., the crane will be the largest-capacity ring crane ever built, setting a new benchmark for major construction projects worldwide.The crane features a modular configuration comprising two main units that work in tandem. The first main unit has completed final assembly and can independently perform lifting operations. Once both..

Next Story
Infrastructure Urban

Thriveni Logistics orders 200 tip trailers from Jagdamba trailers

Jagdamba Trailers (JTPL), one of India’s growing trailer manufacturers, has secured a significant order for 200 Tip Trailers from Thriveni Transport and Logistics Pvt. Ltd., a leading mining and logistics company serving operations across India and overseas.The order, placed for iron ore transportation, is a major milestone for JTPL, particularly as the company secured the business after competing with more than 10 established trailer manufacturers. It also strengthens an already successful relationship between the two companies. Approximately one and a half years ago, Thriveni Transport and..

Advertisement

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

Get daily newsletters around different themes from Construction world.

STAY CONNECTED

Advertisement

SPECIAL OFFER
QR Code