New natural gas tariffs might lead to legal challenges
OIL & GAS

New natural gas tariffs might lead to legal challenges

For a large percentage of consumers, the new consolidated regulations on the tariff of natural gas pipelines notified by the Petroleum and Natural Gas Regulatory Board (PNGRB) may contribute to an increase in tariff. These include steel and fertiliser plants, and this could lead to an upward revision of the government's subsidies spent on urea.

According to several industry experts, the tariff structure informed by the current two-member PNGRB is likely to face legal challenges owing to the effect of the new requirements on existing arrangements between suppliers and consumers of natural gas, including commercial agreements that pipeline developers have signed since bagging projects via a competitive bidding process.

The regulations mark a change from the present scheme, which taxes customers based on the distance from the source of gas and the number of pipelines used to a plan involving a single gas tariff system. It has one tariff for gas being shipped within 300 km and another tariff for gas being transported beyond 300 km from the source of gas.

PNGRB said this step aims to minimise the cost of transporting gas for customers farther away from gas fields, essentially attempting to levy its consumers a weighted average tariff of 14 pipelines, clubbed as the national gas grid, even though they use only one of these pipelines. Some stakeholders said that another difficulty arises from the fact that four of these 14 pipelines were distributed after a competitive tariff-based bidding procedure, with the result that forced improvements to the tariff system now effectively raising question marks about the rightness of the bidding process, some stakeholders said.

Most stakeholders have expressed the opinion that the new tariffs would lead to higher gas distribution rates for industries located near gas supplies, including LNG terminals on the west coast of India, as shown by a majority of the 100-odd stakeholders who submitted their comments to the PNGRB on the draft rule. Fertiliser factories and power plants are among the primary consumers of natural gas located near natural gas infusion points. While talking about the draft regulations, the Ministry of Fertilisers also stated that a rise in the landing costs of natural gas would likely lead to an increase in the government's subsidy burden. It claimed that any upward revision of the pipeline tariff would lead to an increase in the cost of gas delivered to urea production units. This will increase the government's subsidy burden.

In its remarks, the Fertiliser Association of India stated that the current scheme is expected to increase the cost of plants processing 15 million tonnes of urea per annum by more than Rs 400 crore. National Fertilizers Ltd found out that current consumers in the second zone will also cross-subsidise consumers using higher tariff pipelines in the new regime. Experts observed that because the current requirements are set to be revenue-neutral for pipelines, the whole scheme will have to bear any increase in volumes for higher tariff pipelines.

A government official said the Ministry of Petroleum was currently reviewing the regulations and had not received any complaints about the proposed regulations from the industry. The official acknowledged that due to the new rules, including the concerns of the rightness of current contracts and the procurement procedure for bidding out pipelines, significant legal issues could emerge.

According to industry sources, it was possible that the industry players who were adversely impacted by the new tariff regime would oppose the new regulations. The experts have suggested that players in the industry pursuing legal remedies against the new tariff scheme may raise the problem that the position of member (legal) of the board has been vacant since 30 March. The Supreme Court recently suspended the operation of the Central Electricity Regulatory Commission until it appoints a member (legal).

Source: New Indian Express

For a large percentage of consumers, the new consolidated regulations on the tariff of natural gas pipelines notified by the Petroleum and Natural Gas Regulatory Board (PNGRB) may contribute to an increase in tariff. These include steel and fertiliser plants, and this could lead to an upward revision of the government's subsidies spent on urea.According to several industry experts, the tariff structure informed by the current two-member PNGRB is likely to face legal challenges owing to the effect of the new requirements on existing arrangements between suppliers and consumers of natural gas, including commercial agreements that pipeline developers have signed since bagging projects via a competitive bidding process. The regulations mark a change from the present scheme, which taxes customers based on the distance from the source of gas and the number of pipelines used to a plan involving a single gas tariff system. It has one tariff for gas being shipped within 300 km and another tariff for gas being transported beyond 300 km from the source of gas. PNGRB said this step aims to minimise the cost of transporting gas for customers farther away from gas fields, essentially attempting to levy its consumers a weighted average tariff of 14 pipelines, clubbed as the national gas grid, even though they use only one of these pipelines. Some stakeholders said that another difficulty arises from the fact that four of these 14 pipelines were distributed after a competitive tariff-based bidding procedure, with the result that forced improvements to the tariff system now effectively raising question marks about the rightness of the bidding process, some stakeholders said. Most stakeholders have expressed the opinion that the new tariffs would lead to higher gas distribution rates for industries located near gas supplies, including LNG terminals on the west coast of India, as shown by a majority of the 100-odd stakeholders who submitted their comments to the PNGRB on the draft rule. Fertiliser factories and power plants are among the primary consumers of natural gas located near natural gas infusion points. While talking about the draft regulations, the Ministry of Fertilisers also stated that a rise in the landing costs of natural gas would likely lead to an increase in the government's subsidy burden. It claimed that any upward revision of the pipeline tariff would lead to an increase in the cost of gas delivered to urea production units. This will increase the government's subsidy burden. In its remarks, the Fertiliser Association of India stated that the current scheme is expected to increase the cost of plants processing 15 million tonnes of urea per annum by more than Rs 400 crore. National Fertilizers Ltd found out that current consumers in the second zone will also cross-subsidise consumers using higher tariff pipelines in the new regime. Experts observed that because the current requirements are set to be revenue-neutral for pipelines, the whole scheme will have to bear any increase in volumes for higher tariff pipelines. A government official said the Ministry of Petroleum was currently reviewing the regulations and had not received any complaints about the proposed regulations from the industry. The official acknowledged that due to the new rules, including the concerns of the rightness of current contracts and the procurement procedure for bidding out pipelines, significant legal issues could emerge. According to industry sources, it was possible that the industry players who were adversely impacted by the new tariff regime would oppose the new regulations. The experts have suggested that players in the industry pursuing legal remedies against the new tariff scheme may raise the problem that the position of member (legal) of the board has been vacant since 30 March. The Supreme Court recently suspended the operation of the Central Electricity Regulatory Commission until it appoints a member (legal). Source: New Indian Express

Next Story
Infrastructure Energy

KEC Secures Rs 10, 380 Mn Substation Order in Saudi Arabia

KEC International Ltd., a global infrastructure EPC major, and an RPG Group company, has secured a new order worth Rs 10,380 million for the Design, Supply and Installation of a 380 kV GIS Substation in Saudi Arabia.Vimal Kejriwal, MD & CEO, KEC International Ltd., commented, “We are delighted with the successive order wins in our T&D business. In a landmark achievement, we have secured our largest ever substation order. This prestigious order in the Middle East has widened our portfolio and strengthened our presence in the region. With this strategic win, our year-to-date or..

Next Story
Infrastructure Urban

Central Bank of India executes first fully digital SCF deal on PSB Xchange

In a major advancement for India’s banking sector, Central Bank of India (CBI) has successfully completed the country’s first fully digital supply chain finance (SCF) transaction on PSB Xchange—a unified multi-lender platform launched by PSB Alliance. PSB Xchange is designed to connect public and private sector banks, NBFCs, and fintechs with corporates and their channel partners to facilitate supply chain finance and small business loans. The transaction marks the first time a fintech-originated corporate lead has been seamlessly processed through the PSB Xchange ecosystem. The lead fl..

Next Story
Infrastructure Energy

Atlanta Electricals secures Rs 1,835 Mn transformer order from BNC Power

Atlanta Electricals Limited (“Atlanta”) has secured an order worth Rs 1,835 million from BNC Power Projects Ltd for the supply of extra high voltage (EHV) transformers and a bus reactor for its Pugal site. The contract includes a mix of 315 MVA, 400 KV and 100 MVA, 132 KV transformers along with a 400 KV bus reactor. The project scope encompasses design, manufacturing, testing, and supply to the project site. Deliveries will be sequenced following engineering and drawing approvals, offering multi-quarter execution visibility and ensuring a steady production run-rate. The order will be ex..

Advertisement

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

Get daily newsletters around different themes from Construction world.

STAY CONNECTED

Advertisement

Advertisement

Advertisement

Talk to us?