CAG's higher land premium proposal ignored by Ahmedabad civic body

07 Apr 2023 CW Team

The Comptroller Auditor General (CAG) had stated in 2016 that the civic body's slum redevelopment policy was "flawed" and "skewed towards offering cheap land to private bidders," and that it was intended to "cause crores of financial loss" to the Ahmedabad Municipal Corporation (AMC). Despite this, the AMC has yet to make any changes to the policy.

The CAG audited 13 slum redevelopment schemes and discovered that the land premium was fixed without taking into account the formula agreed upon under the state government's "land disposable policy." According to the CAG, this was "illegal" and a clear violation of government policy. So far, the AMC has given builders 50,000 square metres of land divided into ten plots as part of the in-situ slum redevelopment project.

According to the CAG report from 2016, the developer paid a land premium that was 1.49 to 3.3 times higher than the existing jantri for that time period. According to a senior AMC official, "CAG questioned this rate because AMC charged a higher premium when it auctioned land for normal commercial and residential use in 2015."

According to the CAG, between January and July 2015, the AMC fixed a base price that was 2.61 times to 6.59 times higher than the jantri rate for a few plots for commercial and residential projects. It earned 3.2 to 10.94 times the jantri rate for the same plots after the auction.

"The average premium charged by developers participating in slum redevelopment should have been 6.18 times higher than the jantri rate," CAG stated at the time. The state government passed a GR in 2008 that insisted on charging current commercial rates during auctions or sales of government-owned plots.

The AMC had set aside 94,240 square metres of land for slum redevelopment projects. "The CAG's proposal to send slum redevelopment projects to the AMC's estate department's price fixation committee for review was never accepted by the AMC's slum redevelopment project division, resulting in losses worth crores to the AMC," a senior AMC official said.

Also Read
Smart Street, 40-ft-high Wipro gate construction begins in Kolkata
Chilla Elevated Road gets budget approval for Rs 8.01 bn

The Comptroller Auditor General (CAG) had stated in 2016 that the civic body's slum redevelopment policy was flawed and skewed towards offering cheap land to private bidders, and that it was intended to cause crores of financial loss to the Ahmedabad Municipal Corporation (AMC). Despite this, the AMC has yet to make any changes to the policy. The CAG audited 13 slum redevelopment schemes and discovered that the land premium was fixed without taking into account the formula agreed upon under the state government's land disposable policy. According to the CAG, this was illegal and a clear violation of government policy. So far, the AMC has given builders 50,000 square metres of land divided into ten plots as part of the in-situ slum redevelopment project. According to the CAG report from 2016, the developer paid a land premium that was 1.49 to 3.3 times higher than the existing jantri for that time period. According to a senior AMC official, CAG questioned this rate because AMC charged a higher premium when it auctioned land for normal commercial and residential use in 2015. According to the CAG, between January and July 2015, the AMC fixed a base price that was 2.61 times to 6.59 times higher than the jantri rate for a few plots for commercial and residential projects. It earned 3.2 to 10.94 times the jantri rate for the same plots after the auction. The average premium charged by developers participating in slum redevelopment should have been 6.18 times higher than the jantri rate, CAG stated at the time. The state government passed a GR in 2008 that insisted on charging current commercial rates during auctions or sales of government-owned plots. The AMC had set aside 94,240 square metres of land for slum redevelopment projects. The CAG's proposal to send slum redevelopment projects to the AMC's estate department's price fixation committee for review was never accepted by the AMC's slum redevelopment project division, resulting in losses worth crores to the AMC, a senior AMC official said. Also Read Smart Street, 40-ft-high Wipro gate construction begins in Kolkata Chilla Elevated Road gets budget approval for Rs 8.01 bn

Infrastructure Transport

28 Oct 2025

Smart Roads, Smarter India

India’s infrastructure boom is not only about laying more kilometres of highways – it’s about building them smarter, safer and more sustainably. From drones mapping fragile Himalayan slopes to 3D machine-controlled graders reducing human error, technology is steadily reshaping the way projects are planned and executed. Yet, the journey towards digitisation remains complex, demanding not just capital but also coordination, training and vision.Until recently, engineers largely depended on Survey of India toposheets and traditional survey methods like total stations or DGPS to prepare detai..

Real Estate

28 Oct 2025

What Does DCPR 2034 Mean?

The Maharashtra government has eased approval norms for high-rise buildings under DCPR 2034, enabling the municipal commissioner to sanction projects up to 180 m on large plots. This change is expected to streamline approvals, reduce procedural delays and accelerate redevelopment, drawing reactions from developers, planners and industry experts about its implications for Mumbai’s vertical growth.Under the revised DCPR 2034 rules, buildings on plots of 2,000 sq m or more can now be approved up to 180 m by the municipal commissioner, provided structural and geotechnical reports are certified b..

Infrastructure Urban

28 Oct 2025

Driving Infrastructure Forward with Trustworthy AI

At its Year in Infrastructure 2025 conference in Amsterdam, Bentley Systems reaffirmed its vision for trustworthy AI and connected digital ecosystems shaping the future of infrastructure engineering. The company unveiled AI-powered design applications and Bentley Infrastructure Cloud Connect, a unifying platform connecting data, workflows and professionals across the project lifecycle.“AI is poised to transform infrastructure,” said Nicholas Cumins, CEO, Bentley Systems. “At Bentley, our vision is for AI to empower engineers – not replace them. Trustworthy AI, built on infrastruct..