SC criticises Arbitral Award, calls fresh hearing on SE Railway dispute

24 Jan 2024 CW Team

The Supreme Court strongly criticised an arbitral award instructing the South Eastern Railway to pay Rs 13.01 billion to a private firm, asserting that such misuse of public funds cannot be tolerated. The bench, led by Chief Justice D Y Chandrachud and Justices J B Pardiwala and Manoj Misra, expressed initial dissatisfaction with the sole arbitrator's decision, stating, "Less said the better. As judges, we also know a lot of things."

Expressing discontent with the arbitral award, the Chief Justice remarked, "I am not happy with the arbitral award. Let the case go before a dispassionate arbitrator and let this be heard again. If Railways lose there... then it is fine. But, the arbitration process cannot be allowed to be handled like this. This is why the arbitration is getting a bad name."

Emphasising the need to prevent the mismanagement of public funds, the bench stated, "The public money cannot be allowed to go waste like this."

The case pertains to the South Eastern Railway's challenge against the arbitral award favouring Kolkata-based firm Rashmi Metaliks Limited in a contractual dispute.

Despite the Supreme Court's initial reluctance to proceed, it scheduled the hearing for Thursday and directed senior advocate Abhishek Singhvi, representing the private firm, to obtain instructions.

Previously, the Calcutta High Court had granted an "unconditional stay" on the enforcement of the arbitration award, citing "glaring irregularities."

Referring to the observations made by the high court, the Chief Justice stated, "Look at what the high court has observed. We are willing to set aside the order and have a fresh arbitration. We will appoint an arbitrator for this one."

Equipment

12 Dec 2025

Schwing Stetter India Unveils New Innovations at Excon 2025

Schwing Stetter India unveiled more than 20 new machines at Excon 2025, marking one of its most significant showcases and introducing several India-first technologies to the construction equipment sector. The company launched the country’s first 56-metre boom pump designed and manufactured in India, the first fully electric truck mixer, the first CNG mixer variant and the first hybrid boom pump. Executives said the launch portfolio was engineered to support India’s move toward faster, greener and more vertically oriented infrastructure through advanced engineering, clean-energy solutions a..

SEPC Resolves Hindustan Copper Dispute, Wins Rs 725 Mn Order

Engineering, procurement and construction firm SEPC Ltd has recently settled a dispute with Hindustan Copper Ltd (HCL) and secured a mining infrastructure order valued at Rs 725 million from the state-owned company. SEPC informed the stock exchanges that it has executed a settlement deed with HCL, bringing closure to all inter-se claims and counterclaims arising from arbitration proceedings. As part of the settlement, SEPC will receive Rs 304.5 million as full and final payment, marking the resolution of all pending disputes between the two entities. The company also stated that Hindustan Co..

20% Ethanol Blending Cuts India’s CO2 Emissions by 73.6 Mn Tonnes

Union Road Transport and Highways Minister Nitin Gadkari recently said that India has reduced carbon dioxide emissions by 73.6 million metric tonnes due to the adoption of 20 per cent ethanol blending in petrol. He made the statement while replying to supplementary questions during the Question Hour in the Lok Sabha. Describing ethanol as a green fuel, the minister said it plays a key role in reducing pollution while also supporting higher incomes for farmers. He underlined that ethanol blending contributes both to environmental sustainability and rural economic growth. Nitin Gadkari also po..