High Court says retrospective use of black money law unconstitutional

24 Jun 2024 CW Team

Rich Indians and large business families entangled in the stringent black money law are celebrating after the High Court ruled against its retrospective application.

For the first time, the court invoked Article 20 of the Constitution to nullify the retrospective use of the law, which was enacted in 2015 to target offshore bank accounts, properties, and companies of resident Indians.

Article 20 states that "no person shall be convicted of any offence except for violation of a law in force at the time of the commission of the act charged as an offence." In essence, one cannot be punished under a law that did not exist when the offence was committed. The Karnataka High Court quashed the criminal proceedings initiated by the income-tax department against individuals connected to overseas bank accounts and firms that were closed before the Black Money Act came into force. The court ruled that the prosecution against these petitioners did not meet constitutional standards under Article 20. This decision sets a precedent for numerous court cases, as many Indians had closed their bank accounts and companies before 2015 in anticipation of such a law.

However, under Section 72 of the Black Money (Undisclosed Foreign Income and Assets) and Imposition of Tax Act, overseas assets acquired years ago can also be scrutinised. The year the tax office receives the information is considered the year in which a foreign bank account was opened.

Referring to Section 72, Justice M. Nagaprasanna stated that it violates Article 20 of the Constitution. "The Special enactment is a statute. Article 20 comes under Chapter III of the Constitution of India, a fundamental right. The Constitution of India is not a statute. It is the fountainhead of all statutes including the special statute," the court ruled. (Source: ET)

Resources

09 Mar 2026

Haworth India Hosts Women’s Leadership Panel Series

Haworth India marked International Women’s Day by hosting a leadership roundtable series titled ‘Give to Gain’, bringing together senior women leaders from architecture and design firms, corporates and project management consultancies. The series has been conducted in Delhi and Mumbai, with upcoming sessions scheduled in Bengaluru and Hyderabad on 27 March 2026. Structured as moderated panel discussions followed by audience interaction, the initiative examined the business impact of women’s leadership and the role of inclusive workplaces in supporting professional growth. Manish Khan..

Max Estates Secures RERA For Max One Project

Max Estates has secured RERA approval (UPRERA No.: UPRERAPRJ9759) for its Max One development around Max Towers in Sector 16B, Noida, bringing renewed progress to a project previously stalled following the insolvency of its earlier developer. Spread across around 10 acres with an estimated development potential of about 2.5 million sq ft, Max One is planned as an integrated mixed-use campus combining serviced residences, premium offices, retail spaces and a private club. The project is expected to generate total sales potential of about Rs 20 billion along with an estimated annuity rental inc..

Hindware Introduces Starc Smart Wall Mount Toilet

Hindware has introduced the Starc Smart Wall-Mount Toilet under its Hindware Italian Collection, designed to combine automation, hygiene and contemporary bathroom aesthetics. The model features automatic flushing, sensor-based seat opening and closing, and remote-controlled functions. It also includes an oscillating water spray and warm air dryer for cleaning, along with a self-cleaning nozzle designed to maintain hygiene. Additional features include adjustable heated seating, customisable water temperature and pressure settings, a foot-touch flush system and an LCD control interface. The wa..