High Court says retrospective use of black money law unconstitutional
ECONOMY & POLICY

High Court says retrospective use of black money law unconstitutional

Rich Indians and large business families entangled in the stringent black money law are celebrating after the High Court ruled against its retrospective application.

For the first time, the court invoked Article 20 of the Constitution to nullify the retrospective use of the law, which was enacted in 2015 to target offshore bank accounts, properties, and companies of resident Indians.

Article 20 states that "no person shall be convicted of any offence except for violation of a law in force at the time of the commission of the act charged as an offence." In essence, one cannot be punished under a law that did not exist when the offence was committed. The Karnataka High Court quashed the criminal proceedings initiated by the income-tax department against individuals connected to overseas bank accounts and firms that were closed before the Black Money Act came into force. The court ruled that the prosecution against these petitioners did not meet constitutional standards under Article 20. This decision sets a precedent for numerous court cases, as many Indians had closed their bank accounts and companies before 2015 in anticipation of such a law.

However, under Section 72 of the Black Money (Undisclosed Foreign Income and Assets) and Imposition of Tax Act, overseas assets acquired years ago can also be scrutinised. The year the tax office receives the information is considered the year in which a foreign bank account was opened.

Referring to Section 72, Justice M. Nagaprasanna stated that it violates Article 20 of the Constitution. "The Special enactment is a statute. Article 20 comes under Chapter III of the Constitution of India, a fundamental right. The Constitution of India is not a statute. It is the fountainhead of all statutes including the special statute," the court ruled. (Source: ET)

Rich Indians and large business families entangled in the stringent black money law are celebrating after the High Court ruled against its retrospective application. For the first time, the court invoked Article 20 of the Constitution to nullify the retrospective use of the law, which was enacted in 2015 to target offshore bank accounts, properties, and companies of resident Indians. Article 20 states that no person shall be convicted of any offence except for violation of a law in force at the time of the commission of the act charged as an offence. In essence, one cannot be punished under a law that did not exist when the offence was committed. The Karnataka High Court quashed the criminal proceedings initiated by the income-tax department against individuals connected to overseas bank accounts and firms that were closed before the Black Money Act came into force. The court ruled that the prosecution against these petitioners did not meet constitutional standards under Article 20. This decision sets a precedent for numerous court cases, as many Indians had closed their bank accounts and companies before 2015 in anticipation of such a law. However, under Section 72 of the Black Money (Undisclosed Foreign Income and Assets) and Imposition of Tax Act, overseas assets acquired years ago can also be scrutinised. The year the tax office receives the information is considered the year in which a foreign bank account was opened. Referring to Section 72, Justice M. Nagaprasanna stated that it violates Article 20 of the Constitution. The Special enactment is a statute. Article 20 comes under Chapter III of the Constitution of India, a fundamental right. The Constitution of India is not a statute. It is the fountainhead of all statutes including the special statute, the court ruled. (Source: ET)

Next Story
Infrastructure Transport

CPCL crosses $10 million revenue milestone

Chaitanya Projects Consultancy (CPCL), a leading infrastructure and engineering consultancy, has surpassed $10 million in annual revenue for FY 2024–25, marking a five-year compound annual growth rate of 28.2 per cent—well above the industry average. Established in 2004, CPCL has delivered over 300 projects across highways, bridges, urban infrastructure, water, transport, and environmental sectors. Its achievements include over 600 km of six-lane highways, 2,000 km of national highways, and 100 major bridges. “Our goal has always been to improve India’s infrastructure,” sai..

Next Story
Resources

KPIL secures new orders worth Rs 37.89 billion

Kalpataru Projects International Ltd (KPIL), a major EPC player in power transmission and civil infrastructure, has secured new orders worth approximately Rs 37.89 billion along with its international subsidiaries. The orders include a significant contract in the Buildings and Factories (B&F) segment in India, marking KPIL’s largest B&F order to date. The project involves the development of over 12 million sq ft of residential space with supporting infrastructure, awarded on a design-build basis. Additionally, the company has won new transmission and distribution (T&D) order..

Next Story
Real Estate

Apartment loading rises to 40 per cent in top cities

Driven by rising demand for premium amenities, the average apartment loading across India’s top seven cities has reached 40 per cent in Q1 2025, up from 31 per cent in 2019, according to ANAROCK Research. The loading factor, or the area paid for beyond the usable carpet area, covers common spaces such as lobbies, staircases, and clubhouses. Mumbai Metropolitan Region (MMR) continues to lead with the highest loading at 43 per cent. Bengaluru saw the sharpest jump, from 30 per cent in 2019 to 41 per cent in Q1 2025. Chennai recorded the lowest average loading at 36 per cent. “Sixty..

Advertisement

Advertisement

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

Get daily newsletters around different themes from Construction world.

STAY CONNECTED

Advertisement

Advertisement

Advertisement

Advertisement

Talk to us?