Tata Steel to file curative petition on mining tax ruling in SC
COAL & MINING

Tata Steel to file curative petition on mining tax ruling in SC

Tata Steel plans to file a curative petition in the Supreme Court, challenging a July 25 ruling by the court's nine-judge Constitution Bench that affirmed states' authority to impose cess on mining and mineral-use activities. The steel giant, which operates captive mines in Jharkhand and Odisha, aims to seek relief from the implications of this judgment. Despite the ruling, Tata Steel CEO T V Narendran confirmed that no formal demand has been issued to the company.

The origin of the dispute dates back to the Odisha government’s Orissa Rural Infrastructure and Socio-Economic Development Act (ORISED) of 2004, which introduced a tax on mineral-bearing land. This legislation led to a Rs 1.29 billion demand from Odisha on Tata Steel's mining activities, a charge the company successfully contested in the Odisha High Court. However, Odisha escalated the matter to the Supreme Court, resulting in the recent ruling in favour of state levies on minerals, with collections permitted retroactively from April 1, 2005.

Tata Steel disclosed, during its Q2FY25 results, that although Odisha’s appeal is pending before a regular Supreme Court bench, the application and enforcement of the ORISED Act remain uncertain. The company is engaging with state officials to explore viable paths forward, as both the state and central governments acknowledge the importance of not undermining industrial stability. Narendran noted the industry’s changing landscape since ORISED's enactment, highlighting increased state revenue from mining royalties and the establishment of the District Mineral Foundation (DMF), a mining-funded non-profit supporting districts impacted by mining under the MMDR Amendment Act, 2015.

The company’s discussions with authorities reflect shared concerns about balancing state interests and industry health. Narendran remarked that excessive taxation on minerals, like coal, could escalate costs across sectors, notably in energy. Tata Steel had previously disclosed a contingent liability of Rs 173.47 billion for its Odisha mines as of June 30, 2024. However, the Q2FY25 notes clarified that no current legal obligation related to ORISED exists, and thus no financial provision has been recorded in its results.

(Business Standard)

Tata Steel plans to file a curative petition in the Supreme Court, challenging a July 25 ruling by the court's nine-judge Constitution Bench that affirmed states' authority to impose cess on mining and mineral-use activities. The steel giant, which operates captive mines in Jharkhand and Odisha, aims to seek relief from the implications of this judgment. Despite the ruling, Tata Steel CEO T V Narendran confirmed that no formal demand has been issued to the company. The origin of the dispute dates back to the Odisha government’s Orissa Rural Infrastructure and Socio-Economic Development Act (ORISED) of 2004, which introduced a tax on mineral-bearing land. This legislation led to a Rs 1.29 billion demand from Odisha on Tata Steel's mining activities, a charge the company successfully contested in the Odisha High Court. However, Odisha escalated the matter to the Supreme Court, resulting in the recent ruling in favour of state levies on minerals, with collections permitted retroactively from April 1, 2005. Tata Steel disclosed, during its Q2FY25 results, that although Odisha’s appeal is pending before a regular Supreme Court bench, the application and enforcement of the ORISED Act remain uncertain. The company is engaging with state officials to explore viable paths forward, as both the state and central governments acknowledge the importance of not undermining industrial stability. Narendran noted the industry’s changing landscape since ORISED's enactment, highlighting increased state revenue from mining royalties and the establishment of the District Mineral Foundation (DMF), a mining-funded non-profit supporting districts impacted by mining under the MMDR Amendment Act, 2015. The company’s discussions with authorities reflect shared concerns about balancing state interests and industry health. Narendran remarked that excessive taxation on minerals, like coal, could escalate costs across sectors, notably in energy. Tata Steel had previously disclosed a contingent liability of Rs 173.47 billion for its Odisha mines as of June 30, 2024. However, the Q2FY25 notes clarified that no current legal obligation related to ORISED exists, and thus no financial provision has been recorded in its results. (Business Standard)

Next Story
Infrastructure Energy

Vedanta Aluminium Uses 1.57 bn Units of Green Energy in FY25

Vedanta Aluminium, India’s largest aluminium producer, recently reported consumption of 1.57 billion units of renewable energy in FY25, marking a significant milestone in its 2030 decarbonisation roadmap. The company also achieved an 8.96 per cent reduction in greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions intensity compared to FY21, reinforcing its leadership in India’s low-carbon manufacturing transition. During FY25, Vedanta Aluminium expanded its renewable energy portfolio through long-term power purchase agreements, strengthening its strategy to source nearly 1,500 MW of renewable power over the lon..

Next Story
Real Estate

Oberoi Group to Develop Luxury Resort at Makaibari Tea Estate

EIH Limited, the flagship company of The Oberoi Group, has announced the signing of a management agreement to develop an Oberoi luxury resort at the iconic Makaibari Tea Estate in Darjeeling. The project marks a key milestone in the Group’s long-term strategy of creating distinctive hospitality experiences in rare and environmentally significant locations. Established in 1859, Makaibari is one of the world’s oldest tea estates and is globally recognised for its Himalayan landscape, primary forests and exceptional biodiversity. Spread across 1,236 acres, the estate houses one of the world..

Next Story
Real Estate

GHV Infra Secures Rs 1.09 Bn EPC Order in Jamshedpur

GHV Infra Projects Ltd, a fast-growing EPC company in India’s infrastructure and construction sector, has recently secured a Rs 1.09 billion work order in Jamshedpur, Jharkhand. Awarded by a reputed group entity, the contract covers end-to-end civil construction, mechanical, electrical and plumbing (MEP) systems, along with high-quality finishing works for a large building development. The project will be executed over a 30-month period, with defined benchmarks for quality, safety and timely delivery. The order strengthens GHV Infra’s footprint in Jamshedpur, a key industrial hub known fo..

Advertisement

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

Get daily newsletters around different themes from Construction world.

STAY CONNECTED

Advertisement

Advertisement

Advertisement

Advertisement

Open In App