+
CJI Surya Kant Calls for Preventive Justice to Avoid Infrastructure Disputes
ECONOMY & POLICY

CJI Surya Kant Calls for Preventive Justice to Avoid Infrastructure Disputes

Kant has urged the infrastructure ecosystem to design contractual and institutional frameworks that identify and address concerns early through communication and dispute-avoidance mechanisms.

Chief Justice of India Surya Kant has urged India’s infrastructure ecosystem to move from retrospective justice to preventive justice, as the country undertakes projects at an unprecedented scale. Speaking at global engineering body FIDIC’s Global Infrastructure Conference 2026 in New Delhi, Kant said the true measure of a justice system’s success lies in ensuring mechanisms around infrastructure projects function pre-emptively to avoid disputes.

“A legal system should not measure its success only by how effectively it resolves disputes after they have arisen. It should also ask how effectively the institutions around a project prevent those disputes from arising in the first place,” Kant told delegates from more than 70 countries.

He stressed that infrastructure projects cannot afford delays caused by prolonged litigation. “A bridge cannot pause construction while an arbitration proceeds. A highway cannot wait for an appeal to run its course. And a power project cannot suspend its economic purpose while the parties debate the meaning of an unforeseen circumstance,” he said.

Kant argued that contractual and institutional frameworks must be designed to identify and address concerns early through communication and dispute-avoidance mechanisms.

Push for Standardisation
With global stakeholders increasingly involved in infrastructure delivery, Kant reinforced the importance of standardisation. “Infrastructure today rarely respects a single border. Capital may originate in one country, engineering expertise in another, construction capacity in the third, but while the asset itself rises in a country, in an environment as interconnected as this, standardisation becomes important,” he said.

He cautioned against reinventing provisions for payments, variations, extensions of time, unforeseen conditions and dispute resolution for every project, saying this only created uncertainty. While a single court could not be prescribed for all projects given local laws and circumstances, he said standardisation should ensure contracts share a familiar structure while leaving room for project-specific realities.

Role of Legal Profession
Kant said the legal profession had a critical role in improving processes. If disputes about variations, payments, extensions of time or changed site conditions kept recurring, contracts should be drafted differently in future.

“This has particular resonance for India at this moment in its history. We are undertaking infrastructure development at a scale and pace without real precedent in our own past. Our ambition cannot simply be to build more. It must be to build faster, more resiliently, more sustainably, and more productively,” he said.

He added that India needed contracts that create confidence rather than confrontation, procurement systems that reward genuine value rather than merely the lowest bid, and dispute frameworks that resolve disagreements at the pace projects require. He urged stakeholders to focus on clarity of obligations, balanced risk allocation, sensible standardisation, early dispute avoidance, and swift, independent resolution where disputes cannot be avoided.

FIDIC, or the International Federation of Consulting Engineers, headquartered in Geneva, represents national associations of consulting engineers across more than 100 countries and is best known for publishing standard forms of contract widely used in global infrastructure projects. The body is currently holding its annual conference in the national capital, in association with the Consulting Engineers Association of India (CEAI).

-Manish Pant

Kant has urged the infrastructure ecosystem to design contractual and institutional frameworks that identify and address concerns early through communication and dispute-avoidance mechanisms.Chief Justice of India Surya Kant has urged India’s infrastructure ecosystem to move from retrospective justice to preventive justice, as the country undertakes projects at an unprecedented scale. Speaking at global engineering body FIDIC’s Global Infrastructure Conference 2026 in New Delhi, Kant said the true measure of a justice system’s success lies in ensuring mechanisms around infrastructure projects function pre-emptively to avoid disputes.“A legal system should not measure its success only by how effectively it resolves disputes after they have arisen. It should also ask how effectively the institutions around a project prevent those disputes from arising in the first place,” Kant told delegates from more than 70 countries.He stressed that infrastructure projects cannot afford delays caused by prolonged litigation. “A bridge cannot pause construction while an arbitration proceeds. A highway cannot wait for an appeal to run its course. And a power project cannot suspend its economic purpose while the parties debate the meaning of an unforeseen circumstance,” he said.Kant argued that contractual and institutional frameworks must be designed to identify and address concerns early through communication and dispute-avoidance mechanisms.Push for StandardisationWith global stakeholders increasingly involved in infrastructure delivery, Kant reinforced the importance of standardisation. “Infrastructure today rarely respects a single border. Capital may originate in one country, engineering expertise in another, construction capacity in the third, but while the asset itself rises in a country, in an environment as interconnected as this, standardisation becomes important,” he said.He cautioned against reinventing provisions for payments, variations, extensions of time, unforeseen conditions and dispute resolution for every project, saying this only created uncertainty. While a single court could not be prescribed for all projects given local laws and circumstances, he said standardisation should ensure contracts share a familiar structure while leaving room for project-specific realities.Role of Legal ProfessionKant said the legal profession had a critical role in improving processes. If disputes about variations, payments, extensions of time or changed site conditions kept recurring, contracts should be drafted differently in future.“This has particular resonance for India at this moment in its history. We are undertaking infrastructure development at a scale and pace without real precedent in our own past. Our ambition cannot simply be to build more. It must be to build faster, more resiliently, more sustainably, and more productively,” he said.He added that India needed contracts that create confidence rather than confrontation, procurement systems that reward genuine value rather than merely the lowest bid, and dispute frameworks that resolve disagreements at the pace projects require. He urged stakeholders to focus on clarity of obligations, balanced risk allocation, sensible standardisation, early dispute avoidance, and swift, independent resolution where disputes cannot be avoided.FIDIC, or the International Federation of Consulting Engineers, headquartered in Geneva, represents national associations of consulting engineers across more than 100 countries and is best known for publishing standard forms of contract widely used in global infrastructure projects. The body is currently holding its annual conference in the national capital, in association with the Consulting Engineers Association of India (CEAI).-Manish Pant

Related Stories

Gold Stories

Next Story
Infrastructure Urban

CAFE-III Gives Auto Industry Investment Clarity

The government’s new Corporate Average Fuel Economy (CAFE-III) norms have provided the automobile industry with a clearer framework for technology investments, according to industry representatives. The framework seeks to balance environmental objectives with flexibility for manufacturers while encouraging the adoption of flex-fuel vehicles and biofuels. Society of Indian Automobile Manufacturers (SIAM) President Shenu Agarwal said the five-year framework would give automakers greater predictability to plan investments and accelerate innovation. He said the regulation established annual targ..

Next Story
Infrastructure Energy

Mines Ministry to Auction Two Offshore Mineral Blocks in Andaman Sea

The Ministry of Mines will launch an auction of two offshore mineral blocks in the Andaman Sea on Thursday, seeking to unlock India’s offshore mineral potential and strengthen long-term mineral resource security. The blocks will be offered under a composite licence, which permits exploration and development activities in accordance with the applicable regulatory framework. The ministry said the auction was intended to encourage systematic exploration, attract investment and promote the use of advanced technologies for offshore mineral exploration and development. The initiative is also aimed..

Next Story
Infrastructure Energy

India Invites Global Mining Community to India Mining Week 2026

India has invited the global mining community to participate in India Mining Week 2026, seeking international collaboration, expertise and investment to support the development of the country’s mining and minerals sector. The event is scheduled to be held from November 15 to 17, 2026, at Yashobhoomi in New Delhi. Coal Additional Secretary Rupinder Brar extended the invitation while addressing India Mining: Global Connect, an international outreach interaction involving representatives from diplomatic missions in 19 countries. The meeting focused on opportunities for greater international par..

Advertisement

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

Get daily newsletters around different themes from Construction world.

STAY CONNECTED

Advertisement

SPECIAL OFFER
QR Code