GST Authorities Issue Notices to Developers Over Rs 35 Billion Claims

23 Dec 2024 CW Team

These notices follow a Supreme Court ruling in October regarding Safari Retreats, which allowed commercial real estate companies to claim ITC on construction costs for rental buildings.

The GST authorities have sought the refund of ITC from the developers, arguing that the credits were wrongly claimed, and in some cases, they have blocked the credit claims altogether. A developer who received a notice mentioned that the notices were causing significant confusion among industry players.

The Supreme Court had upheld the constitutional validity of the relevant provisions while emphasizing that eligibility for ITC should be determined on a case-by-case basis, based on the "essentiality" and "functionality" tests. The Court also specified that two conditions must be met to avail tax credit: the property must either be leased out or sold before construction is complete, and it must qualify as "plant or machinery."

Authorities stated that credits claimed by real estate companies would be deemed eligible once it is conclusively established that they meet the functionality and essentiality tests outlined by the Supreme Court.

Many developers have already approached the court in response to these notices, claiming that tax officials are misusing the provision to block and deny ITC. Tax officials explained that they are carefully reviewing ITC claims to prevent potential misuse. Abhishek A. Rastogi, the founder of Rastogi Chambers, argued that a scientific and objective mechanism must be applied uniformly to determine eligibility, in order to avoid unjustly denying rightful credits.

He also pointed out that in certain cases, authorities are interpreting the Supreme Court's findings as applying only to the petitioners in the Safari Retreats case. He stated that this interpretation is flawed, as judicial precedents are binding and should be applied uniformly to all taxpayers in similar situations across the industry.

Your next big infra connection is waiting at RAHSTA 2025 – Asia’s Biggest Roads & Highways Expo, Jio World Convention Centre, Mumbai. Don’t miss out!

Several property developers have reportedly received show-cause notices from the Goods and Services Tax (GST) authorities, questioning their claims for input tax credit (ITC) amounting to approximately Rs 35 billion, according to sources familiar with the matter. These notices follow a Supreme Court ruling in October regarding Safari Retreats, which allowed commercial real estate companies to claim ITC on construction costs for rental buildings. The GST authorities have sought the refund of ITC from the developers, arguing that the credits were wrongly claimed, and in some cases, they have blocked the credit claims altogether. A developer who received a notice mentioned that the notices were causing significant confusion among industry players. The Supreme Court had upheld the constitutional validity of the relevant provisions while emphasizing that eligibility for ITC should be determined on a case-by-case basis, based on the essentiality and functionality tests. The Court also specified that two conditions must be met to avail tax credit: the property must either be leased out or sold before construction is complete, and it must qualify as plant or machinery. Authorities stated that credits claimed by real estate companies would be deemed eligible once it is conclusively established that they meet the functionality and essentiality tests outlined by the Supreme Court. Many developers have already approached the court in response to these notices, claiming that tax officials are misusing the provision to block and deny ITC. Tax officials explained that they are carefully reviewing ITC claims to prevent potential misuse. Abhishek A. Rastogi, the founder of Rastogi Chambers, argued that a scientific and objective mechanism must be applied uniformly to determine eligibility, in order to avoid unjustly denying rightful credits. He also pointed out that in certain cases, authorities are interpreting the Supreme Court's findings as applying only to the petitioners in the Safari Retreats case. He stated that this interpretation is flawed, as judicial precedents are binding and should be applied uniformly to all taxpayers in similar situations across the industry.

Infrastructure Transport

01 Sep 2025

Indian Railways Marks New Milestone with 4.5 km Long ‘Rudrastra’ Trial

Indian Railways has successfully conducted the trial run of Asia’s longest freight train, named ‘Rudrastra’, achieving a new milestone in cargo transportation, as per news reports. The 4.5 km-long train began its trial from Ganjkhwaja railway station in Chandauli, Uttar Pradesh, and travelled to Garhwa in Jharkhand. Covering a distance of 209 km in 5 hours and 10 minutes, it maintained an average speed of 40.5 km per hour. The train was formed by combining three long-haul racks, with ..

Infrastructure Energy

01 Sep 2025

UltraTech Launches India’s First On-Site Hybrid RTC Renewable Energy Project

UltraTech Cement has operationalised a 7.5 MW round-the-clock (RTC) hybrid renewable energy project at its Sewagram Cement Works in Gujarat. The first-of-its-kind solution combines bifacial solar modules with trackers, wind energy and battery storage, co-located on-site, to ensure uninterrupted power for cement manufacturing without grid reliance. The project was executed in collaboration with clean energy solutions provider Gentari. Installed as a behind-the-meter system, it is the country..

Infrastructure Transport

09 Sep 2025

Patna Metro Trials Successful, Red Line Priority Corridor to Launch This Month

Patna is set to roll out its first metro rail service later this month, with successful trial runs conducted on the Red Line priority corridor, the Patna Metro Rail Corporation announced.On 7 September, a metro train completed a test run between the Patna depot and Bhootnath station. Officials said the trials involved rigorous checks of rolling stock fitness, overhead electrification (OHE), and track alignment and stability to ensure operational safety and performance.The corridor from the New Pataliputra Bus Terminal to Bhoothnath has been designated as the priority stretch and will be the fi..