BBMP Fines Consultants for Nashik Malegaon Mix-Up in Tunnel Road DPR
ROADS & HIGHWAYS

BBMP Fines Consultants for Nashik Malegaon Mix-Up in Tunnel Road DPR

The executive summary of the Detailed Project Report (DPR) presented an analysis to understand traffic characteristics between Malegaon and Nashik cities in Maharashtra. However, this incorrect reference raised concerns, as the report was meant to assess traffic volumes on Malur Road, Guttahalli Main Road, and NR Road for a study involving nine cordon points across an 18-kilometer tunnel connecting Hebbal Esteem Mall junction to Silk Board KSRP junction.

The Bruhat Bengaluru Mahanagara Palike (BBMP) imposed a penalty of Rs 0.5 million on Rodic Consultants, a New Delhi-based firm responsible for preparing the DPR, citing flaws in the compilation of its executive summary. The consultancy had received a contract worth Rs 90.5 million for the project.

BBMP clarified that the error was not present in the original draft DPR but emerged during the compilation of the executive summary by Rodic Consultants. BS Prahallad, Engineer-in-Chief, BBMP, mentioned that the consultants acknowledged the mistake and apologized for it. He noted that the discrepancy between the draft report and the executive summary was taken seriously, leading to the financial penalty. The BBMP emphasised its intent to encourage more constructive public engagement.

The DPR faced criticism from activists and civic groups, who accused it of being a "copy-paste" document due to the mistaken references to Malegaon and Nashik. Questions were also raised about the feasibility of finalizing such a large-scale project report in just three months.

In response to these allegations, BBMP Chief Commissioner Tushar Giri Nath refuted claims of a "copy-paste" job. He acknowledged the error in the executive summary but maintained that other sections of the report remained accurate. He remarked that despite the firm's mistake and subsequent penalization, labelling the entire DPR as flawed due to a minor issue was unjustified.

The tunnel project, a key initiative led by DK Shivakumar, Deputy Chief Minister and Bengaluru Development Minister, has drawn severe criticism from mobility activists and civic groups who argue it undermines principles of sustainable transportation. Nonetheless, the government defended the project, highlighting its potential to decongest roads, reduce pollution, provide high-speed connectivity, and save fuel.

To fund the Rs 190-billion project, for which BBMP has sought a loan, the state government agreed to act as guarantor. Nine banks have already expressed interest in financing the venture, which is projected to be completed in 61 months.

The executive summary of the Detailed Project Report (DPR) presented an analysis to understand traffic characteristics between Malegaon and Nashik cities in Maharashtra. However, this incorrect reference raised concerns, as the report was meant to assess traffic volumes on Malur Road, Guttahalli Main Road, and NR Road for a study involving nine cordon points across an 18-kilometer tunnel connecting Hebbal Esteem Mall junction to Silk Board KSRP junction. The Bruhat Bengaluru Mahanagara Palike (BBMP) imposed a penalty of Rs 0.5 million on Rodic Consultants, a New Delhi-based firm responsible for preparing the DPR, citing flaws in the compilation of its executive summary. The consultancy had received a contract worth Rs 90.5 million for the project. BBMP clarified that the error was not present in the original draft DPR but emerged during the compilation of the executive summary by Rodic Consultants. BS Prahallad, Engineer-in-Chief, BBMP, mentioned that the consultants acknowledged the mistake and apologized for it. He noted that the discrepancy between the draft report and the executive summary was taken seriously, leading to the financial penalty. The BBMP emphasised its intent to encourage more constructive public engagement. The DPR faced criticism from activists and civic groups, who accused it of being a copy-paste document due to the mistaken references to Malegaon and Nashik. Questions were also raised about the feasibility of finalizing such a large-scale project report in just three months. In response to these allegations, BBMP Chief Commissioner Tushar Giri Nath refuted claims of a copy-paste job. He acknowledged the error in the executive summary but maintained that other sections of the report remained accurate. He remarked that despite the firm's mistake and subsequent penalization, labelling the entire DPR as flawed due to a minor issue was unjustified. The tunnel project, a key initiative led by DK Shivakumar, Deputy Chief Minister and Bengaluru Development Minister, has drawn severe criticism from mobility activists and civic groups who argue it undermines principles of sustainable transportation. Nonetheless, the government defended the project, highlighting its potential to decongest roads, reduce pollution, provide high-speed connectivity, and save fuel. To fund the Rs 190-billion project, for which BBMP has sought a loan, the state government agreed to act as guarantor. Nine banks have already expressed interest in financing the venture, which is projected to be completed in 61 months.

Next Story
Infrastructure Urban

Reliance, Diehl Advance Pact for Precision-Guided Munitions

Diehl Defence CEO Helmut Rauch and Reliance Group’s Founder Chairman Anil D. Ambani have held discussions to advance their ongoing strategic partnership focused on Guided and Terminally Guided Munitions (TGM), under a cooperation agreement originally signed in 2019.This collaboration underscores Diehl Defence’s long-term commitment to the Indian market and its support for the Indian Government’s Make in India initiative. The partnership’s current emphasis is on the urgent supply of the Vulcano 155mm Precision Guided Munition system to the Indian Armed Forces.Simultaneously, the “Vulc..

Next Story
Infrastructure Urban

Modis Navnirman to Migrate to Main Board, Merge Subsidiary

Modis Navnirman Limited has announced that its Board of Directors has approved a key strategic initiative involving migration from the BSE SME platform to the Main Board of both BSE and NSE, alongside a merger with its wholly owned subsidiary, Shree Modis Navnirman Private Limited.The move to the main boards marks a major milestone in the company’s growth trajectory, reflecting its consistent financial performance, robust corporate governance, and long-term commitment to value creation. This transition will grant the company access to a broader investor base, improve market participation, en..

Next Story
Infrastructure Urban

Global Capital Flows Remain Subdued, EMEA Leads in Q1 2025

The Bharat InvITs Association’s industry update for Q1 2025 shows subdued global capital flows, with investment volumes remaining at the lower end of the five-year range despite a late 2024 recovery. According to data from Colliers and MSCI Real Capital Analytics, activity in North America declined slightly, while EMEA maintained steady levels and emerged as the top region for investment in standing assets.The EMEA region now hosts seven of the top ten cross-border capital destinations for standing assets, pushing the United States’ share of global activity below 15 per cent. Meanwhile, in..

Advertisement

Advertisement

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

Get daily newsletters around different themes from Construction world.

STAY CONNECTED

Advertisement

Advertisement

Advertisement

Advertisement

Talk to us?