Bengaluru Civic Body Faces Criticism for Tunnel Road Report Errors
ROADS & HIGHWAYS

Bengaluru Civic Body Faces Criticism for Tunnel Road Report Errors

A detailed project report (DPR) for an ambitious tunnel road project in Bengaluru, Karnataka, has raised concerns after it was found to contain several inaccuracies, including environmental discrepancies and references to cities in Maharashtra. The DPR, prepared by New Delhi-based Rodic Consultants and submitted to the Bruhat Bengaluru Mahanagara Palike (BBMP) in November 2024, outlined plans for an 18 km tunnel road connecting Hebbal and Silk Board, at a cost of Rs 90.5 million.

The report, completed in just three months, has been criticised for including traffic volume data from two cities in Maharashtra while discussing traffic patterns in Bengaluru. A specific section of the report, which analyses traffic volumes at Malur Road, Guttahalli Main Road, and NR Road, mentions traffic characteristics between Malegaon and Nashik, prompting concerns of a "copy-paste" job.

The report stated that nine cordon points had been identified to understand the traffic characteristics in the study area, followed by a detailed account of traffic flow and counts at various junctions. However, the inclusion of traffic data from cities far from Bengaluru has led to questions about the validity of the entire report.

The tunnel project, which is estimated to cost Rs 126.90 billion, aims to alleviate traffic congestion between the two key junctions, Hebbal and Silk Board. The proposed tunnel is designed to reduce travel time from 90 minutes to just 20 minutes, with three intermediate ramps at Mekhri Circle, Racecourse, and Lalbagh, improving connectivity along the North-South Corridor.

Karnataka’s Deputy Chief Minister DK Shivakumar, who has been advocating for the project as part of his “Brand Bengaluru” initiative, believes the tunnel will significantly reduce traffic congestion, particularly at the busy Hebbal and Silk Board junctions.

In addition to the DPR, the BBMP had also commissioned a feasibility study for the same corridor from Altinok Consulting at a cost of Rs 40.7 million.

The report’s quick turnaround, completed in just three months, raised concerns among observers, as DPRs typically take nine months to a year to prepare. For comparison, the DPR for Bengaluru Metro’s 37-km Hebbal-Sarjapur corridor, prepared by RINA Consulting at a cost of Rs 10.5 million, took a full year to complete. This stark difference in both cost and timelines has further fuelled scrutiny regarding the planning process of the tunnel project.

A detailed project report (DPR) for an ambitious tunnel road project in Bengaluru, Karnataka, has raised concerns after it was found to contain several inaccuracies, including environmental discrepancies and references to cities in Maharashtra. The DPR, prepared by New Delhi-based Rodic Consultants and submitted to the Bruhat Bengaluru Mahanagara Palike (BBMP) in November 2024, outlined plans for an 18 km tunnel road connecting Hebbal and Silk Board, at a cost of Rs 90.5 million. The report, completed in just three months, has been criticised for including traffic volume data from two cities in Maharashtra while discussing traffic patterns in Bengaluru. A specific section of the report, which analyses traffic volumes at Malur Road, Guttahalli Main Road, and NR Road, mentions traffic characteristics between Malegaon and Nashik, prompting concerns of a copy-paste job. The report stated that nine cordon points had been identified to understand the traffic characteristics in the study area, followed by a detailed account of traffic flow and counts at various junctions. However, the inclusion of traffic data from cities far from Bengaluru has led to questions about the validity of the entire report. The tunnel project, which is estimated to cost Rs 126.90 billion, aims to alleviate traffic congestion between the two key junctions, Hebbal and Silk Board. The proposed tunnel is designed to reduce travel time from 90 minutes to just 20 minutes, with three intermediate ramps at Mekhri Circle, Racecourse, and Lalbagh, improving connectivity along the North-South Corridor. Karnataka’s Deputy Chief Minister DK Shivakumar, who has been advocating for the project as part of his “Brand Bengaluru” initiative, believes the tunnel will significantly reduce traffic congestion, particularly at the busy Hebbal and Silk Board junctions. In addition to the DPR, the BBMP had also commissioned a feasibility study for the same corridor from Altinok Consulting at a cost of Rs 40.7 million. The report’s quick turnaround, completed in just three months, raised concerns among observers, as DPRs typically take nine months to a year to prepare. For comparison, the DPR for Bengaluru Metro’s 37-km Hebbal-Sarjapur corridor, prepared by RINA Consulting at a cost of Rs 10.5 million, took a full year to complete. This stark difference in both cost and timelines has further fuelled scrutiny regarding the planning process of the tunnel project.

Next Story
Equipment

Handling concrete better

Efficiently handling the transportation and placement of concrete is essential to help maintain the quality of construction, meet project timelines by minimising downtimes, and reduce costs – by 5 to 15 per cent, according to Sandeep Jain, Director, Arkade Developers. CW explores what the efficient handling of concrete entails.Select wellFirst, a word on choosing the right equipment, such as a mixer with a capacity aligned to the volume required onsite, from Vaibhav Kulkarni, Concrete Expert. “An overly large mixer will increase the idle time (and cost), while one that ..

Next Story
Real Estate

Elevated floors!

Raised access flooring, also called false flooring, is a less common interiors feature than false ceilings, but it has as many uses – if not more.A raised floor is a modular panel installed above the structural floor. The space beneath the raised flooring is typically used to accommodate utilities such as electrical cables, plumbing and HVAC systems. And so, raised flooring is usually associated with buildings with heavy cabling and precise air distribution needs, such as data centres.That said, CW interacted with designers and architects and discovered that false flooring can come in handy ..

Next Story
Infrastructure Urban

The Variation Challenge

A variation or change in scope clause is defined in construction contracts to take care of situations arising from change in the defined scope of work. Such changes may arise due to factors such as additions or deletions in the scope of work, modifications in the type, grade or specifications of materials, alterations in specifications or drawings, and acts or omissions of other contractors. Further, ineffective planning, inadequate investigations or surveys and requests from the employer or those within the project’s area of influence can contribute to changes in the scope of work. Ext..

Advertisement

Advertisement

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

Get daily newsletters around different themes from Construction world.

STAY CONNECTED

Advertisement

Advertisement

Advertisement

Advertisement

Talk to us?