+
Cement

"Successful Strategies for Effective Team Communication and Collaboration"

Building value must be an aspect at the prime location in our minds while taking any long-term decision in any and every project, emphasises CHETAN RAIKAR.Any structure is constructed mostly out of natural resources. Cement is made from limestone, steel is m...

Building value must be an aspect at the prime location in our minds while taking any long-term decision in any and every project, emphasises CHETAN RAIKAR.Any structure is constructed mostly out of natural resources. Cement is made from limestone, steel is made from iron ore, and  so on. There are hardly any materials of construction that are purely inorganic in nature.We have two distinct types of structures available for use currently – the heritage structures, and the more recent ones constructed in steel and concrete. Most consultants prefer to reconstruct the older structures than to repair them. This is probably due to the following reasons: 1) The improved land use (to utilise the FSI ) and the commercial benefits derived out of the same. 2) Technical inability of the consultant to do value analysis of repairs versus reconstruction. 3) Present day needs of the user and society. The impactSome of the heritage structures are saved due to the statute, fortunately. Any reconstruction project has environmental impacts and permanent detrimental effects such as: 1) Creation of huge quantity of debris disposed as landfill in most cases. 2) Use of natural resources in construction of the new structure and the carbon footprint of the same. 3) Consumption of energy in demolition and reconstruction that substantially higher compared to repairs. 4) Nuisance and disturbance to the neighbourhood and infrastructure in densely populated areas.Factors like environmental impact of the action, social impact and other aspects must be considered before taking a final decision of demolishing a structure.A global view for valueHeritage structures last for centuries since they have a huge quantum of strength reserve. The materials used in constructing them, such as stone, timber, lime, etc, are more durable compared to the newer-age construction materials. The techniques of construction used in heritage structures are more towards making low-stress structures and having a higher factor of safety and strength reserve in the structures, when compared to the techniques used nowadays. This is primarily the reason these structures last for centuries, with much less maintenance demands. This is one more reason why a decision of demolishing a heritage structure should not be taken, easily.Value engineering, as applied on structures is a major need of the society, the Mother Earth, and hence the animal kingdom, which includes human race. Demolition for the sake of commercial gains should be a big ‘NO’! Since the commercial gains are only for a handful of people whereas it is a permanent loss to the society and people at large.Building value should always, hence, be weighed much above the direct tangible benefits to some and more global view must be taken by the authorities.I strongly recommend considering the following before deciding about repairs versus reconstruction: 1) Is the decision being taken for commercial gains of few? 2) Is Mother Nature being damaged permanently in the process? 3) How is the debris going to recycled (and not dumped at a landfill)? 4) Is there a gain or loss in the energy consumption of the universe? The commissioner of Mumbai recently made a statement that more than half the city of Mumbai would be under 1 m of water in the next couple of decades or so. This is an alarming statement from a responsible bureaucrat. This issue ust be taken seriously. We, the construction industry, must reverse the damage that we cause to Mother Nature and “building value” must be an aspect at the prime location in our minds while taking any long-term decision in any and every project.About the author: Chetan Raikar, Chairman and Managing Director, Structwel Designers and Consultants, is a professional structural engineer with a true passion in conservation of heritage structures. He has achieved great heights of success by crediting some of the notable heritage conservation projects to his stride; making him one of the renowned conservationists in the country today.

Related Stories

Gold Stories

Next Story
Infrastructure Transport

Mumbai-Ahmedabad Bullet Train’s Surat-Vapi Section Set for 2027

The first section of the Mumbai-Ahmedabad Bullet Train corridor, linking Surat and Vapi, is targeted to begin services in 2027. Construction is expected to be completed by December 2026, while Railway Minister Ashwini Vaishnaw has indicated that an inauguration could take place around the middle of 2027. The National High Speed Rail Corporation (NHSRCL) said the train being manufactured in India is expected to reach the tracks around April or May 2027. The train will undergo extensive testing before the section is opened for passenger services. The project began construction in 2021 and includ..

Next Story
Infrastructure Transport

Indian Railways Approves Four Projects Worth Rs. 7.36 bn Across Four States

Indian Railways has approved four projects with a combined value of Rs. 7.36 bn across Uttar Pradesh, Maharashtra, Andhra Pradesh and Gujarat. The programme covers train protection, signalling, electric traction supply and a road overbridge, with each project assigned to a different railway zone. In Uttar Pradesh, Rs. 2.52 bn has been approved to extend the Kavach 4.0 automatic train protection system across 607.7 km in the Lucknow Division of North Eastern Railway. The system monitors train movements and can apply the brakes if a driver fails to observe a signal or exceeds a safe speed. The w..

Next Story
Infrastructure Urban

Chandru Raheja Sells 1.49% Stake in Mindspace REIT for Rs. 5 bn

Billionaire Chandru Lachmandas Raheja has sold a 1.49 per cent holding in Mindspace Business Parks REIT for Rs. 5 bn through a bulk deal on the BSE. The transaction involved 9.9 mn units and was executed at an average price of Rs. 505 per unit, according to exchange data. Following the sale, units of Mindspace Business Parks REIT were trading 0.18 per cent lower at Rs. 504.05 on Tuesday. Exchange data did not identify the buyers involved in the transaction. Raheja is the chairman of real estate company K Raheja Corp. The sale involved 99,00,990 units, representing 1.49 per cent of the Mumbai-b..

Advertisement

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

Get daily newsletters around different themes from Construction world.

STAY CONNECTED

Advertisement

SPECIAL OFFER
QR Code