Bombay High Court Criticizes Maharashtra Slum Policy
Real Estate

Bombay High Court Criticizes Maharashtra Slum Policy

In a significant judgement, the Bombay High Court termed Maharashtra's slum policy as "strange" and lamented that an international city like Mumbai is known for its slums. A division bench of Justices Girish Kulkarni and Jitendra Jain criticized the policy that grants free tenements to encroachers, highlighting the detrimental impact on both public and private land ownership.

The court pointed out that this policy has led to substantial tracts of land being diverted from the "state pool," affecting future generations. It emphasized the need for a thorough reassessment of such government policies, noting the severe consequences for Mumbai's urban landscape.

Once slums on private land are recognized under the Slum Act, the encroachment becomes a legitimate right to free tenement for the encroachers, the court observed. This, according to the bench, effectively rewards illegal encroachment, compromising the rights of rightful landowners.

Highlighting the challenge of evicting encroachers, the court expressed concern over the disappearance of major public lands in Mumbai, now subject to private development under the guise of slum redevelopment. The Slum Rehabilitation Authority (SRA), the court noted, bears a significant responsibility to protect property rights objectively and lawfully.

The bench quashed an October 2021 notice from the SRA seeking to acquire land from the Mount Mary Church trust in Bandra for a slum redevelopment project, declaring the acquisition "patently illegal." The court was responding to a petition from Bishop John Rodrigues, representing the church trust, challenging the SRA's move to acquire 1,596 square meters of their land.

The judges reiterated that slum-dwellers are entitled only to permanent alternate accommodation under statutory schemes, not ownership rights over the land. They criticized the state policy for encouraging widespread encroachment, resulting in significant losses for both public and private landowners.

The court underscored the need for a comprehensive review of these policies to safeguard the rights of future generations and ensure adherence to constitutional principles. Acknowledging the necessity of housing for a large migrant workforce, the bench stressed that this should not come at the expense of violating property rights and legal principles.

In conclusion, the court highlighted the complex reality of removing encroachments in Mumbai, noting the involvement of slumlords, criminals, social workers, and politicians who exploit these situations for electoral gains. The court's remarks call for immediate and thoughtful policy revisions to address these deep-seated urban challenges.

In a significant judgement, the Bombay High Court termed Maharashtra's slum policy as strange and lamented that an international city like Mumbai is known for its slums. A division bench of Justices Girish Kulkarni and Jitendra Jain criticized the policy that grants free tenements to encroachers, highlighting the detrimental impact on both public and private land ownership. The court pointed out that this policy has led to substantial tracts of land being diverted from the state pool, affecting future generations. It emphasized the need for a thorough reassessment of such government policies, noting the severe consequences for Mumbai's urban landscape. Once slums on private land are recognized under the Slum Act, the encroachment becomes a legitimate right to free tenement for the encroachers, the court observed. This, according to the bench, effectively rewards illegal encroachment, compromising the rights of rightful landowners. Highlighting the challenge of evicting encroachers, the court expressed concern over the disappearance of major public lands in Mumbai, now subject to private development under the guise of slum redevelopment. The Slum Rehabilitation Authority (SRA), the court noted, bears a significant responsibility to protect property rights objectively and lawfully. The bench quashed an October 2021 notice from the SRA seeking to acquire land from the Mount Mary Church trust in Bandra for a slum redevelopment project, declaring the acquisition patently illegal. The court was responding to a petition from Bishop John Rodrigues, representing the church trust, challenging the SRA's move to acquire 1,596 square meters of their land. The judges reiterated that slum-dwellers are entitled only to permanent alternate accommodation under statutory schemes, not ownership rights over the land. They criticized the state policy for encouraging widespread encroachment, resulting in significant losses for both public and private landowners. The court underscored the need for a comprehensive review of these policies to safeguard the rights of future generations and ensure adherence to constitutional principles. Acknowledging the necessity of housing for a large migrant workforce, the bench stressed that this should not come at the expense of violating property rights and legal principles. In conclusion, the court highlighted the complex reality of removing encroachments in Mumbai, noting the involvement of slumlords, criminals, social workers, and politicians who exploit these situations for electoral gains. The court's remarks call for immediate and thoughtful policy revisions to address these deep-seated urban challenges.

Next Story
Infrastructure Energy

J&K CM Rules Out Power Privatisation, Focuses on Sector Reform

Jammu and Kashmir Chief Minister Omar Abdullah has dismissed speculation regarding privatisation of electricity in the Union Territory, emphasising that his priority is to strengthen and reform the power sector.“We are not discussing privatisation. By reducing losses, improving billing efficiency, and enhancing revenue, there will be no need for it. My vision is to strengthen and reform the power sector in J&K,” Abdullah stated.He addressed the gathering at the 58th Engineers’ Day at SKICC on Monday evening, an event honouring Bharat Ratna Sir M Visvesvaraya for his pioneering contri..

Next Story
Infrastructure Urban

Mumbai’s Sassoon Dock to Get Tech-Driven Modernisation with Finland

The Maharashtra government, in collaboration with Finland, will modernise Mumbai’s historic Sassoon Dock using advanced technology, state minister Nitesh Rane announced on Wednesday.Rane met a delegation of Finnish officials and representatives of Finnish companies at the dock to discuss strategic plans for upgrading the facility in south Mumbai, according to an official statement.Built in the 19th century, Sassoon Dock is one of Mumbai’s oldest and busiest fishing harbours. Operations currently exceed its original capacity, raising concerns over hygiene, odour, fish handling standards, an..

Next Story
Infrastructure Energy

Agarwal Industrial Wins Rs 3.3 Billion IOCL Bitumen Tender

Agarwal Industrial Corporation rose 3.84 per cent to Rs 945.65 after announcing it had secured a prestigious tender from Indian Oil Corporation (IOCL) worth Rs 3.3 billion.In a regulatory filing during market hours, the company confirmed it had won the tender to supply Bulk Bitumen (VG-30 and VG-40 grades) to IOCL’s Kakinada locations.The firm quantity under the award totals around 60,500 tonnes across 11 parcels, while the optional quantity is approximately 33,000 tonnes across six parcels. This brings the total awarded quantity to roughly 93,500 tonnes. At current market prices, the firm o..

Advertisement

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

Get daily newsletters around different themes from Construction world.

STAY CONNECTED

Advertisement

Advertisement

Advertisement

Talk to us?