ITAT Remands Tax Deduction Case for Verification of Flats as Single Unit
ECONOMY & POLICY

ITAT Remands Tax Deduction Case for Verification of Flats as Single Unit

The Mumbai bench of the Income-Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT) has remanded a tax deduction case involving two adjoining flats back to the Income Tax (I-T) authorities for further verification. The taxpayer, P Shah, claimed a tax deduction of Rs.95 million under Section 54-F of the Income-Tax Act for her investment in the flats during the 2020-21 financial year.

Under Section 54-F, a taxpayer can sell long-term assets, such as equity shares, and invest the entire net sales consideration in one residential house within a specified period to receive a full tax exemption on the long-term capital gains from the sale. If only part of the net sale consideration is invested in a residential house, the exemption is allowed proportionately. Shah contended that her investment in both adjoining flats constituted a single residential unit, allowing her to claim the full deduction.

The issue of whether investments in two adjoining flats can be treated as a single unit has been contentious. During the tax assessment, the I-T official disputed this claim, citing an amendment effective from the 2014-15 financial year, which stated that a taxpayer can only invest in one residential flat. The official noted that the flats were registered separately and separated by an 'open to sky' space, thus disqualifying them as a single unit.

The commissioner (appeals) initially ruled in favor of Shah, referencing an affidavit from the builder and a revised building plan, indicating an agreement to convert the adjoining flats into one unit. However, the I-T department deemed these documents "self-serving" and filed an appeal with the ITAT.

The ITAT found that no physical verification had been conducted by the tax authorities regarding the flats' status as a single residential unit. Consequently, the case has been sent back to the I-T officer for physical verification. The tribunal noted that if the flats are indeed combined, Shah would qualify for the tax deduction.

The Mumbai bench of the Income-Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT) has remanded a tax deduction case involving two adjoining flats back to the Income Tax (I-T) authorities for further verification. The taxpayer, P Shah, claimed a tax deduction of Rs.95 million under Section 54-F of the Income-Tax Act for her investment in the flats during the 2020-21 financial year. Under Section 54-F, a taxpayer can sell long-term assets, such as equity shares, and invest the entire net sales consideration in one residential house within a specified period to receive a full tax exemption on the long-term capital gains from the sale. If only part of the net sale consideration is invested in a residential house, the exemption is allowed proportionately. Shah contended that her investment in both adjoining flats constituted a single residential unit, allowing her to claim the full deduction. The issue of whether investments in two adjoining flats can be treated as a single unit has been contentious. During the tax assessment, the I-T official disputed this claim, citing an amendment effective from the 2014-15 financial year, which stated that a taxpayer can only invest in one residential flat. The official noted that the flats were registered separately and separated by an 'open to sky' space, thus disqualifying them as a single unit. The commissioner (appeals) initially ruled in favor of Shah, referencing an affidavit from the builder and a revised building plan, indicating an agreement to convert the adjoining flats into one unit. However, the I-T department deemed these documents self-serving and filed an appeal with the ITAT. The ITAT found that no physical verification had been conducted by the tax authorities regarding the flats' status as a single residential unit. Consequently, the case has been sent back to the I-T officer for physical verification. The tribunal noted that if the flats are indeed combined, Shah would qualify for the tax deduction.

Next Story
Infrastructure Transport

Metro Line 2B Phase 1 to Boost Realty in Mumbai’s Eastern Suburbs

Mumbai’s real estate sector is set for a major boost as Phase 1 of Metro Line 2B, between Mandale and Diamond Garden, nears completion. The Mumbai Metropolitan Region Development Authority (MMRDA) has confirmed that mandatory rectifications are done, and inspections by the Commissioner of Metro Railway Safety (CMRS) have been carried out. The 5.39-km stretch with five stations forms part of the larger DN Nagar–Mandale corridor, designed to ease congestion and improve east–west connectivity. Passenger operations are expected by December 2025, with the full line slated for 2027. ..

Next Story
Resources

WattPower wins Best Inverter award at Global Solar Expo 2025

WattPower, a leading renewable energy solutions provider, has won the award for “Best Inverter in the Utility Segment” at the Global Solar Expo 2025. The recognition underscores the company’s commitment to delivering reliable, high-performance and future-ready solar solutions for large-scale projects. At the forefront of utility-scale solar, WattPower manufactures advanced string inverters that directly feed power into the Indian grid. With robust technology, high-quality components and comprehensive product lifecycle support, its solutions stand among the most sophisticated in the ..

Next Story
Real Estate

Awfis delivers 67,000 sq. ft. innovation hub for eBay in Bengaluru

Awfis Space Solutions, India’s largest flexible workspace provider and the first publicly listed workspace solutions platform, has partnered with eBay to establish a 67,000 sq. ft. innovation hub at Embassy Tech Village, Bengaluru. The mandate covers design, build and management of the new office, which will act as a strategic hub supporting diverse functions and accelerating eBay’s AI-first commerce strategy. The centre will focus on artificial intelligence, engineering, product development and applied research, strengthening eBay’s growth in India. Embassy Tech Village, North Beng..

Advertisement

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

Get daily newsletters around different themes from Construction world.

STAY CONNECTED

Advertisement

Advertisement

Advertisement

Talk to us?