Bombay High Court Partly Upholds Metro One Arbitral Award
RAILWAYS & METRO RAIL

Bombay High Court Partly Upholds Metro One Arbitral Award

The Bombay High Court partly allowed a petition filed by the Mumbai Metropolitan Region Development Authority (MMRDA) challenging an arbitral award in favour of Mumbai Metro One Private Limited (MMOPL) over the Versova to Ghatkopar corridor. Justice Sandeep Marne upheld some elements of the 2023 majority award while setting aside several high value claims. The court applied severability.

MMOPL was formed as a special purpose vehicle under the concession agreement dated seven March 2007 on a Build Own Operate Transfer model, with Reliance Infrastructure holding 69 per cent, Veolia five per cent and the authority 26 per cent. The dispute concerned claimed escalation of project costs allegedly caused by delays. A three member tribunal in August 2023 delivered a two to one award granting MMOPL claims aggregating to Rs 9.92 bn, while a dissenting arbitrator rejected the claims and MMRDA challenged the award under Section 34.

On 10 June a High Court bench directed MMRDA to deposit Rs 11.69 bn for a conditional stay, and the Supreme Court on 14 July 2025 subsequently stayed that interim order subject to the authority depositing half of the awarded amount. The authority deposited nearly Rs 5.6 bn and the Supreme Court clarified that its order would not preclude the High Court from finally deciding the challenge. Interim orders influenced the parties' positions while the final contest proceeded.

Justice Marne sustained MMOPL entitlement to Rs 350 mn for deductions from viability gap funding, Rs 131.6 mn for rent at Wadala, Rs 304.8 mn for a steel bridge at Andheri and Rs 1.6322 bn for system works. However, the court set aside claims for additional overheads of Rs 1 bn, financing and interest expenses of Rs 1.25 bn and opportunity costs exceeding Rs 230 mn as unsustainable. The court declined litigation costs and reduced arbitration costs from Rs 10 mn to Rs 5 mn.

The court allowed intervention by National Asset Reconstruction Company Limited (NARCL). It ordered deposits moved to project escrow but stayed transfer for eight weeks.

The Bombay High Court partly allowed a petition filed by the Mumbai Metropolitan Region Development Authority (MMRDA) challenging an arbitral award in favour of Mumbai Metro One Private Limited (MMOPL) over the Versova to Ghatkopar corridor. Justice Sandeep Marne upheld some elements of the 2023 majority award while setting aside several high value claims. The court applied severability. MMOPL was formed as a special purpose vehicle under the concession agreement dated seven March 2007 on a Build Own Operate Transfer model, with Reliance Infrastructure holding 69 per cent, Veolia five per cent and the authority 26 per cent. The dispute concerned claimed escalation of project costs allegedly caused by delays. A three member tribunal in August 2023 delivered a two to one award granting MMOPL claims aggregating to Rs 9.92 bn, while a dissenting arbitrator rejected the claims and MMRDA challenged the award under Section 34. On 10 June a High Court bench directed MMRDA to deposit Rs 11.69 bn for a conditional stay, and the Supreme Court on 14 July 2025 subsequently stayed that interim order subject to the authority depositing half of the awarded amount. The authority deposited nearly Rs 5.6 bn and the Supreme Court clarified that its order would not preclude the High Court from finally deciding the challenge. Interim orders influenced the parties' positions while the final contest proceeded. Justice Marne sustained MMOPL entitlement to Rs 350 mn for deductions from viability gap funding, Rs 131.6 mn for rent at Wadala, Rs 304.8 mn for a steel bridge at Andheri and Rs 1.6322 bn for system works. However, the court set aside claims for additional overheads of Rs 1 bn, financing and interest expenses of Rs 1.25 bn and opportunity costs exceeding Rs 230 mn as unsustainable. The court declined litigation costs and reduced arbitration costs from Rs 10 mn to Rs 5 mn. The court allowed intervention by National Asset Reconstruction Company Limited (NARCL). It ordered deposits moved to project escrow but stayed transfer for eight weeks.

Next Story
Real Estate

Loomcraft Enters South India with Kerala Store Launch

Loomcraft has launched its exclusive store in Kerala, marking its entry into South India and a key step in its nationwide expansion strategy. The move targets a region driven by tourism and premium real estate demand, where outdoor spaces play a central role in hospitality and residential experiences.Kerala’s growing base of luxury resorts, boutique hotels, villas and gated communities has created strong demand for specialised outdoor furniture. However, the region has remained underserved, with buyers relying on imports or generic products not suited to humid, coastal and monsoon-heavy cond..

Next Story
Building Material

Mild Steel Prices Seen Rising to Rs 61,000 Per Tonne

Mild steel prices in India, currently around Rs 58,000 per tonne, are expected to rise to nearly Rs 61,000 per tonne in April, indicating an increase of about Rs 3,000 per tonne. The anticipated rise reflects structural pressures driven by geopolitical tensions, energy constraints and limited raw material availability.Ongoing global conflict has disrupted energy markets, leading to LNG shortages that are affecting domestic steel production. Small and mid-sized manufacturers, particularly those dependent on gas-based processes, are witnessing production cuts due to constrained energy supply, re..

Next Story
Infrastructure Urban

Vedanta Expands Transgender Workforce to 75 Employees

Vedanta has strengthened its commitment to workplace inclusion by employing 75 transgender individuals across its businesses, including Vedanta Aluminium, Hindustan Zinc, Sesa Goa, FACOR and Cairn Oil & Gas. The initiative reflects sustained hiring efforts since 2022 to build equitable opportunities across operations, corporate and technical roles.Transgender employees are engaged in functions such as operations, finance, logistics, HR, CSR, healthcare and security, with provisions for internal mobility to support career progression. The company has implemented structured policies, includi..

Advertisement

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

Get daily newsletters around different themes from Construction world.

STAY CONNECTED

Advertisement

Advertisement

Advertisement